Introducing Market Penetration Intelligence: See Where the Medicare Market Is Actually Moving
Insurance News

Introducing Market Penetration Intelligence: See Where the Medicare Market Is Actually Moving

Where is the opportunity? Which markets are growing? Where is Medicare Advantage gaining ground? Where is Medicare Supplement still strong? Which carriers dominate a particular market? And perhaps most importantly: where should I be spending my time and marketing dollars?

I
InsuranceTalk Staff
datainsurancemedicarefinal expense

Insurance agents spend a lot of time asking the same basic questions.

Where is the opportunity?

Which markets are growing?

Where is Medicare Advantage gaining ground?

Where is Medicare Supplement still strong?

Which carriers dominate a particular market?

And perhaps most importantly: where should I be spending my time and marketing dollars?

Those sound like simple questions. Getting useful answers to them isn't always so simple.

There is an enormous amount of insurance data available publicly. The problem is that much of it exists inside spreadsheets, government databases, carrier reports and other sources that were never designed with the working insurance agent in mind.

Finding data is one thing.

Turning it into something useful is another.

That's the idea behind our newest intelligence tool: Market Penetration Intelligence.

The tool takes Medicare market data and organizes it geographically and historically, allowing agents to see not just what a market looks like today, but how that market has been changing over time.

And while Medicare agents may be the most obvious users of the tool, the information can tell Final Expense agents quite a bit as well.

Stop Looking at the Market as One Big Number

We frequently talk about Medicare Advantage at the national level.

Medicare Advantage enrollment is growing.

More seniors are choosing MA.

Medigap remains strong.

Those statements can all be useful, but they don't necessarily tell an individual insurance agent very much.

Insurance isn't sold nationally.

It is sold locally.

An agent working in Central Florida doesn't really care that Medicare Advantage gained enrollment nationally if the counties that agent works in are behaving differently.

Likewise, knowing that Medicare Supplement enrollment is strong nationally doesn't tell you which states have particularly strong Medigap markets or which carriers are capturing those policyholders.

The national numbers can hide enormous differences underneath them.

One county may have very high Medicare Advantage penetration.

A neighboring county may have substantially lower penetration.

One state may have a thriving Medicare Supplement market dominated by several carriers. Another may be highly concentrated among only one or two companies.

And perhaps even more important than the current number is the direction of the trend.

That's where historical data becomes valuable.

Medicare Advantage Data Down to the County Level

The Medicare Advantage portion of Market Penetration Intelligence allows users to examine historical MAPD penetration across the country at the county level.

That level of detail matters.

Imagine two counties.

County A has relatively high Medicare Advantage penetration, but enrollment has barely changed over several years.

County B has lower overall penetration, but its Medicare Advantage share has been steadily increasing.

Which market is more interesting?

There isn't necessarily one correct answer.

An established Medicare agent might see County A as attractive because consumers are already familiar with Medicare Advantage and there is a large existing population of MA members.

Another agent might look at County B and see an emerging market where consumer behavior appears to be shifting toward Medicare Advantage.

The important thing is that the agent can see the difference.

Instead of simply being told that "Medicare Advantage is growing," the agent can start asking:

Where is it growing?

How quickly is it growing?

Has that growth been consistent?

Which counties are behaving differently from the surrounding market?

Those are much more useful questions.

Historical Data Tells a Different Story

A snapshot tells you where the market is.

A trend tells you where the market may be going.

That's an important distinction.

Suppose a county has 50% Medicare Advantage penetration.

By itself, that's useful information.

But what if penetration was 30% several years ago?

Now we know something else is happening.

That county isn't simply an MA market. It has been a rapidly expanding MA market.

Now consider another county with 60% penetration that has remained between 58% and 61% for years.

The second county still has greater Medicare Advantage penetration, but the first county may be experiencing a much more significant change in consumer behavior.

Neither data point is inherently better.

They simply tell different stories.

Market Penetration Intelligence is designed to make those stories easier to see.

Medigap Looks Different — So We Built It Differently

Medicare Supplement is a different market from Medicare Advantage, and the data needs to be looked at differently.

The Medigap side of Market Penetration Intelligence provides historical Medicare Supplement information at the state level.

This allows agents to examine the size and direction of Medicare Supplement markets across the country.

But we wanted to go further than simply showing enrollment.

The tool also includes carrier market share data.

That opens up an entirely different layer of market intelligence.

An agent can see which companies hold the largest share of a state's Medicare Supplement business and how the competitive landscape is structured.

Is the market dominated by one carrier?

Are the top two or three companies controlling most of the business?

Or is enrollment spread across a much larger group of insurers?

That information can be valuable when evaluating a market.

A large Medigap market isn't necessarily an easy market to enter.

If one or two companies have an overwhelming share, an agent may want to understand why.

Is it pricing?

Brand recognition?

A long-established block of business?

Distribution?

Rate stability?

Agent relationships?

Market share data doesn't automatically answer those questions.

But it tells you where to start asking them.

And that is what good market intelligence should do.

A Tool for Medicare Agents — But Not Only Medicare Agents

At first glance, a database tracking Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement penetration sounds like something built exclusively for Medicare agents.

It isn't.

There is another group that should pay attention to this information:

Final Expense agents.

The connection may not be immediately obvious, but Medicare data can provide valuable clues about the senior insurance market.

Medicare beneficiaries are one of the core demographics Final Expense agents are trying to reach.

Knowing where Medicare populations are concentrated — and understanding the type of Medicare coverage those consumers are choosing — can help an agent develop a more informed marketing strategy.

Consider a Final Expense agent deciding between several markets for direct mail, digital advertising or lead generation.

Instead of choosing counties based purely on population, the agent can begin examining the Medicare landscape as another piece of the puzzle.

A county with a large and growing Medicare population may deserve attention.

A market experiencing significant Medicare Advantage growth may indicate an active senior insurance marketplace with consumers regularly interacting with insurance agents, carriers and Medicare marketing.

Areas with different Medicare coverage patterns may also respond differently to particular marketing approaches.

The tool isn't intended to say:

"Market Final Expense here."

No single dataset can make that decision.

But it can help an agent make that decision with more information.

Combine Medicare penetration with demographics, household income, age, population growth, lead costs and an agent's own production data, and suddenly geographic targeting becomes much more sophisticated.

Instead of asking:

"Where should I buy leads?"

The question becomes:

"What does the data tell me about this market before I spend the money?"

That's a much better question.

Finding Markets You Might Have Overlooked

One of the most interesting uses of market data isn't confirming what you already know.

It's finding something you didn't know.

Most agents naturally develop geographic biases.

We know our home market.

We know where other agents seem to be writing business.

We hear which states are "good Med Supp states."

We hear which counties are supposedly dominated by Medicare Advantage.

Over time, conventional wisdom develops.

Sometimes it's correct.

Sometimes it's outdated.

And sometimes everyone is looking at the same obvious market while a less obvious opportunity is developing somewhere else.

Historical market penetration data provides another way of looking for those opportunities.

Maybe a cluster of counties is showing unusually strong MAPD growth.

Maybe a state's Medicare Supplement market is larger than expected.

Maybe a carrier has quietly gained significant Medigap market share.

Maybe a state that isn't normally discussed by agents has an interesting competitive structure.

None of those observations automatically mean an agent should enter the market.

But they can identify places worth investigating.

That's the difference between data and intelligence.

Data gives you numbers. Intelligence gives you somewhere to look.

It Can Also Help Agents Understand Their Existing Market

Market Penetration Intelligence isn't only about expansion.

It can also help agents understand what's happening in their own backyard.

An agent might feel that Medicare Advantage has become more dominant locally.

The county-level historical data can help determine whether that perception is actually supported by the numbers.

A Medigap producer may feel that a particular carrier is becoming more important in the state.

Market share data can provide additional context.

An agency owner might notice that production has shifted from Medicare Supplement toward Medicare Advantage.

Instead of assuming the change is entirely internal, the agency can compare its experience against broader market trends.

That can lead to better questions.

Are we losing Medigap business?

Or is the entire market changing?

Are our MA sales increasing because our agents are improving?

Or is Medicare Advantage penetration increasing rapidly throughout our counties?

Are we overproducing with one carrier relative to its statewide market share?

Are we underrepresented with another?

Those are the types of questions that can turn a simple dashboard into a business tool.

Better Data Doesn't Replace Experience

There is an important limitation to any intelligence tool.

Numbers don't know everything.

A county can look fantastic on a spreadsheet and still be a terrible market for a particular agent.

Provider networks matter.

Carrier contracts matter.

Lead costs matter.

Competition matters.

Commission structures matter.

Underwriting matters.

Local demographics matter.

And sometimes an experienced agent knows something about a market that won't appear in a government dataset for another year.

Market Penetration Intelligence isn't designed to replace that experience.

It is designed to give experience more context.

The best decisions usually aren't made entirely by instinct or entirely by data.

They're made when the two agree.

And when they don't agree, that's often where things become interesting.

Building a Different Kind of Insurance Intelligence

Market Penetration Intelligence is part of a larger idea we're working toward.

Insurance professionals have access to an incredible amount of information, but much of it remains fragmented.

Underwriting information lives in carrier guides.

Rate activity is scattered across markets.

Enrollment data sits in spreadsheets and government databases.

Carrier market share exists in reports most agents will never read.

And some of the most valuable information exists only inside the experiences of agents working in the field.

The goal of these intelligence tools is to begin bringing those pieces together in ways that are actually useful.

The Medicare Supplement Underwriting Intelligence tool helps agents compare underwriting situations.

The Final Expense Underwriting Intelligence tool helps agents navigate medical conditions and carrier differences.

The Rate Shock Radar helps identify what agents are seeing in the market.

And now Market Penetration Intelligence helps answer another question:

Where is the business?

Not based on someone's opinion.

Not based on which market happens to be getting discussed the most.

And not based solely on where an agent has always worked.

Based on the numbers.

The Map Is Only the Beginning

There is no magic dataset that can tell an insurance agent exactly where the next sale will come from.

That's not what this tool is supposed to do.

What it can do is make the market a little easier to understand.

It can show where Medicare Advantage penetration has been growing.

It can show how counties compare.

It can show how Medicare Supplement markets have changed.

It can show which carriers control Medigap market share within individual states.

And it can give Medicare and Final Expense agents another source of information before deciding where to spend their time, money and attention.

For years, insurance agents have had access to more data than most of us could ever realistically analyze.

The problem was never a lack of numbers.

The problem was turning those numbers into something useful.

Market Penetration Intelligence is our attempt to do exactly that.

Because knowing how big a market is can be useful.

Knowing how that market got there is better.

And seeing where it may be heading is where things start getting interesting.

Comments

Join the conversation

Log in to leave a comment on this article.

Log In